Whole Earth
Whole Earth Smooth Peanut Butter 454g
No value lost·no change on record
0/ 100
Brand head-to-head
Peanut butter
91%declared peanuts
340g · £2.75 (£0.81/100g)
£0.89 per 100g of peanuts
What the actual peanuts costs, filler stripped out
Least peanuts
Sainsbury's
96%declared peanuts
340g · £1.25 (£0.37/100g)
£0.38 per 100g of peanuts
What the actual peanuts costs, filler stripped out
Best buy
Whole Earth
Whole Earth Smooth Peanut Butter 454g
96%declared peanuts
454g · £4.75 (£1.05/100g)
£1.09 per 100g of peanuts
What the actual peanuts costs, filler stripped out
This pack
Three smooth peanut butters on the same shelf, judged on the one number the label buries: how much roasted peanut went in per 100g, the rest being oil, sugar and salt. The Sainsbury's own jar matches premium Whole Earth on peanut content at 96% but costs a third as much per pound of peanut, so it gives the most real peanut for your money. Whole Earth is the dearest per pound of peanut despite its no-added-sugar recipe, and Skippy has the least peanut at 91%.
Ranked by cost per 100g of actual peanuts — shelf price with filler stripped. Sources on each pack's own page.
How the score is built
Shrink · quantityNo data
No pack-size change on record for this product.
Skimp · qualityNo data
No recipe change on record for this product.
Value Erosion Score 0/100. We have no documented change for this product yet. How we score.
The receipts
- Jun 2026Recipe96% peanuts96% roasted peanuts (the rest sustainable palm oil and sea salt, no added sugar), level with the Sainsbury's jar for the most peanut. GBP4.75 standard for 454g, about GBP1.09 per 100g of real peanut, the dearest per pound of peanut despite the no-added-sugar recipe.Verifiedocado.com
Sources
- Verifiedocado.com